What is a Container vs Virtual Machine?

Understanding Containerization Concepts - Part 1

What is a Container vs Virtual Machine?

Let me explain these two concepts from the very basics.

First: What is a Virtual Machine (VM)?

Simple Analogy:

Imagine you have a Windows laptop. But you also need to use macOS for some work.

Old Solution: Buy another physical computer

Buy a MacBook (expensive!)
Now you have 2 physical computers on your desk
Takes space, costs money, uses more electricity

Better Solution: Virtual Machine

Use software to create a "fake" computer INSIDE your Windows laptop
This fake computer thinks it's a real Mac
You can run macOS inside this fake computer
All on ONE physical laptop!

Visual:

Your Physical Laptop (Windows):
├── Windows Operating System (Real)
│
└── Virtual Machine Software (VirtualBox/VMware)
    │
    └── [Virtual Machine - Fake Computer]
        ├── Fake CPU
        ├── Fake RAM (4GB allocated from your real 16GB)
        ├── Fake Hard Drive (50GB file on your real drive)
        └── macOS Operating System (Running inside)
            └── Your Mac applications

How Virtual Machines Work

The Detailed Picture:

Physical Computer (Host Machine):
├── Hardware (Real)
│   ├── CPU (Intel i7)
│   ├── RAM (16GB)
│   └── Hard Drive (512GB)
│
├── Host Operating System (Windows 11)
│
└── Hypervisor (VM Manager - like VirtualBox)
    │
    ├── [Virtual Machine 1]
    │   ├── Guest OS (Ubuntu Linux) ← Full OS!
    │   ├── Allocated: 4GB RAM, 2 CPU cores
    │   └── Apps: Python, Node.js, Database
    │
    ├── [Virtual Machine 2]
    │   ├── Guest OS (macOS) ← Another Full OS!
    │   ├── Allocated: 4GB RAM, 2 CPU cores
    │   └── Apps: Xcode, Safari
    │
    └── [Virtual Machine 3]
        ├── Guest OS (Windows 10) ← Yet Another Full OS!
        ├── Allocated: 4GB RAM, 2 CPU cores
        └── Apps: MS Office, Visual Studio

Key Point: Each VM has its OWN complete Operating System!

Virtual Machine - Real-Life Example

Think of it like Building Multiple Houses:

Your Land (Physical Computer):
│
├── [House 1 - Virtual Machine 1]
│   ├── Complete house with:
│   ├── Foundation
│   ├── Walls
│   ├── Roof
│   ├── Plumbing
│   ├── Electrical system
│   ├── HVAC system
│   └── Everything a house needs!
│
├── [House 2 - Virtual Machine 2]
│   ├── Another complete house with:
│   ├── Its own foundation
│   ├── Its own walls
│   ├── Its own roof
│   ├── Its own plumbing
│   ├── Its own electrical
│   └── Everything SEPARATE!
│
└── [House 3 - Virtual Machine 3]
    └── Yet another FULL house...

Each house (VM) is complete and independent, but it's HEAVY and uses lots of resources!

Problems with Virtual Machines

1. Very Heavy (Resource Intensive):

Physical Computer: 16GB RAM

Virtual Machine 1:
├── Guest OS (Ubuntu) uses 2GB RAM
├── Apps use 2GB RAM
└── Total: 4GB RAM

Virtual Machine 2:
├── Guest OS (Windows) uses 2GB RAM
├── Apps use 2GB RAM
└── Total: 4GB RAM

Virtual Machine 3:
├── Guest OS (macOS) uses 2GB RAM
├── Apps use 2GB RAM
└── Total: 4GB RAM

Total RAM used: 12GB (just for 3 VMs!)
Only 4GB left for your host OS!

Each VM needs:

Entire Operating System (2-3GB)
Lots of RAM
Lots of CPU power
Lots of disk space (20-50GB per VM)

2. Slow to Start:

Starting a Virtual Machine:
├── Boot the entire OS (30-60 seconds)
├── Load system services (20-30 seconds)
├── Start your application (10 seconds)
└── Total: 1-2 minutes to start!

3. Takes Lots of Disk Space:

Virtual Machine 1: 40GB (includes full OS)
Virtual Machine 2: 35GB (includes full OS)
Virtual Machine 3: 45GB (includes full OS)
Total: 120GB of disk space!

4. Waste of Resources:

If you just want to run a simple Python app:

Do you really need an ENTIRE Operating System?
Do you need all the GUI, system services, drivers, etc.?
It's like using a truck to transport a small box!

Now: What is a Container?

Simple Analogy:

Instead of building multiple complete houses (VMs), what if we had one house with multiple rooms?

One House (Your Computer):
├── Shared foundation (OS Kernel)
├── Shared plumbing (OS Services)
├── Shared electrical (System Resources)
│
├── [Room 1 - Container 1]
│   └── Just the furniture and people for App 1
│
├── [Room 2 - Container 2]
│   └── Just the furniture and people for App 2
│
└── [Room 3 - Container 3]
    └── Just the furniture and people for App 3

Each room (container) is isolated but shares the house infrastructure!

How Containers Work

The Detailed Picture:

Physical Computer (Host Machine):
├── Hardware (Real)
│   ├── CPU (Intel i7)
│   ├── RAM (16GB)
│   └── Hard Drive (512GB)
│
├── Host Operating System (Linux) ← ONE OS for all!
│
├── Docker Engine (Container Manager)
│
├── [Container 1]
│   ├── NO separate OS! (uses host OS kernel)
│   ├── Just App files and dependencies
│   ├── Uses: 200MB RAM, shares CPU
│   └── App: Python app with libraries
│
├── [Container 2]
│   ├── NO separate OS! (uses host OS kernel)
│   ├── Just App files and dependencies
│   ├── Uses: 150MB RAM, shares CPU
│   └── App: Node.js app with libraries
│
└── [Container 3]
    ├── NO separate OS! (uses host OS kernel)
    ├── Just App files and dependencies
    ├── Uses: 180MB RAM, shares CPU
    └── App: Database

Key Point: Containers share the host OS but are still isolated from each other!

Container - Real-Life Example

Think of it like Apartments in a Building:

Apartment Building (Your Computer):
├── Shared Infrastructure:
│   ├── One foundation (OS Kernel)
│   ├── One plumbing system (System services)
│   ├── One electrical grid (Hardware resources)
│   └── One HVAC (Shared resources)
│
├── [Apartment 1 - Container 1]
│   ├── Private space
│   ├── Own furniture
│   ├── Own belongings
│   └── But uses building's infrastructure
│
├── [Apartment 2 - Container 2]
│   ├── Private space
│   ├── Own furniture
│   ├── Own belongings
│   └── But uses building's infrastructure
│
└── [Apartment 3 - Container 3]
    ├── Private space
    ├── Own furniture
    ├── Own belongings
    └── But uses building's infrastructure

Much more efficient than building separate houses!

Benefits of Containers

1. Very Lightweight:

Physical Computer: 16GB RAM

Container 1:
├── NO Guest OS
├── Just App + dependencies: 200MB
└── Total: 200MB RAM

Container 2:
├── NO Guest OS
├── Just App + dependencies: 150MB
└── Total: 150MB RAM

Container 3:
├── NO Guest OS
├── Just App + dependencies: 180MB
└── Total: 180MB RAM

Total RAM used: 530MB (for 3 containers!)
Compare to VMs: 12GB for same number!

2. Very Fast to Start:

Starting a Container:
├── No OS boot needed (already running)
├── Just start the application
└── Total: 1-5 seconds! ⚡

3. Small Disk Space:

Container 1: 100MB (just app files)
Container 2: 80MB (just app files)
Container 3: 120MB (just app files)
Total: 300MB
Compare to VMs: 120GB for same number!

4. Efficient Resource Usage:

You can run 50-100 containers on the same machine where you could only run 3-5 VMs!

Side-by-Side Comparison

Virtual Machine:

[Virtual Machine 1]
├── Full OS (2-3GB) ← Heavy!
├── System services ← Uses CPU
├── Drivers ← Takes space
├── GUI components ← Memory hog
└── Your App (small)

Startup time: 1-2 minutes
Size: 20-50GB
RAM: 2-4GB minimum

Container:

[Container 1]
├── Your App
├── App dependencies only
└── Uses host OS (shared)

Startup time: 1-5 seconds ⚡
Size: 50-500MB
RAM: 50-500MB

CodeWithGagan | Programming Language and IT Lectures